Search Catalog

OEM vs Aftermarket Truck Parts: Which Should You Buy?

, 3 min read

OEM vs Aftermarket Truck Parts: Which Should You Buy?

OEM vs aftermarket truck parts is one of the most common questions owner-operators and fleet managers face. OEM parts promise fit and quality at a higher price; aftermarket truck parts promise savings, with quality that ranges from excellent to dangerous.

This guide defines each type, explains 5 honest differences, lists parts worth buying OEM, where aftermarket is fine, and where remanufactured parts fit in.

OEM vs aftermarket truck parts: definitions

  • OEM truck parts (original equipment manufacturer) are made by or for the truck or engine maker, to their specifications, and sold under their brand.
  • Aftermarket truck parts are made by other companies to fit the same trucks. Some match or exceed OEM quality; others are made down to a price.
  • Remanufactured parts start as used OEM cores and are rebuilt to specification, tested and sold with a warranty.

5 honest differences

OEM Aftermarket
Fit Designed for the exact application Usually good from reputable brands, variable from others
Quality Consistent Ranges widely
Price Higher Lower
Warranty Manufacturer’s Varies by brand and seller
Availability Through dealers, sometimes slow Widely available

Parts to buy OEM

  • Engine electronics and sensors: wrong or poor-quality sensors feed bad data to the ECM and cause derates and false faults.
  • Injectors and high-pressure fuel parts: tolerances are tight and failures are expensive. Genuine or quality remanufactured only.
  • Critical safety parts: steering components and key brake valves.
  • Parts under engine warranty: to avoid warranty disputes.

Counterfeit parts are a real risk in this category. See how to spot counterfeit Cummins parts.

Where aftermarket is fine

  • Lighting, mirrors and body parts.
  • Filters from well-known filter brands.
  • Brake linings and drums from reputable makers that meet the required standards.
  • Hoses, belts and clamps from known brands.
  • Cab comfort and accessory items.

Where remanufactured fits

For expensive components such as ECMs, starters, alternators and turbos, remanufactured parts often give the best of both: OEM-based quality, a warranty and a lower price. For engine computers in particular, a remanufactured unit programmed for your engine is usually better value than new and safer than used.

Our remanufactured ECMs for Caterpillar, Cummins and Detroit engines ship pre-programmed with a 1-year warranty. Read remanufactured truck parts and browse our ECMs.

Think about total cost

The cheapest part is not always the cheapest repair. Add the labor to fit it, the downtime if it fails early and the cost of any damage it causes. A good-quality aftermarket filter may be excellent value; a cheap sensor that fails in three months and strands the truck is not.

For each part, ask what happens if it fails. The bigger the consequence, the more it is worth paying for OEM truck parts or a quality remanufactured unit.

Questions to ask before buying

Ask the seller who makes the part, what standard it meets, what the warranty covers and what happens if it does not fit. A reputable seller of aftermarket truck parts answers clearly. If they cannot, buy OEM truck parts or a quality remanufactured unit instead.

Frequently asked questions

Are aftermarket truck parts as good as OEM?

Some are, some are not. Buy from reputable brands and suppliers, and use OEM or quality reman for engine electronics and fuel systems.

Do aftermarket parts void the warranty?

Not automatically, but a failure caused by an aftermarket part may not be covered. Check your warranty terms.

Is remanufactured the same as aftermarket?

No. Remanufactured parts are rebuilt from original parts and tested; aftermarket parts are newly made by other companies.

Should I buy an OEM or remanufactured ECM?

For most trucks, a remanufactured ECM programmed for your engine gives the best value.

Need an ECM?

Call 726-999-0231 or contact us with your part number. General background on remanufactured parts is on Wikipedia’s remanufacturing page.

See all ECM guides

Not sure which ECM you need?

Send us your engine model and serial number, or the part number on your ECM, and we'll tell you whether to repair or replace it, and what it costs.